The
Battle of Bear Valley
Arizona,
9 January 1918
Yaqui warriors of the Mexican Revolution period
Something a little different as this
is a skirmish game I`ve written to try and simulate this interesting
historic engagement on my tabletop. I don`t claim it is a
historically accurate recreation my plan is to create a playable,
enjoyable game.
Readers please note in the text I often refer to the US 10th Cavalry (the famous Buffalo Soldiers) as US 10th Cavalry (colored), this isn`t meant as a racist slur, but is the units actual full title in this period of history.
Background
The
Battle
of Bear Valley
was
a small engagement fought in 1918 between a band of Yaquis
and
a detachment of US Army
soldiers.
On January 9, 1918, elements of the American 10th Cavalry Regiment (colored)
detected
about thirty armed Yaquis
in
Bear Valley, west of Nogales, Arizona, a large area that was commonly
used as a passage across the international border with Mexico. A
short firefight ensued, which resulted in the death of the Yaqui
commander and the capture of nine others. Though the conflict was
merely a skirmish, it was the last time the US Army and indigenous
natives
engaged
in combat and thus has been seen as the final official battle of the
American Indian Wars!
By
1918 the Yaqui people had been at war with Mexico for several years,
the former hoping to establish an independent state in Sonora,
centered on the Rio Yaqui
and
its confluence with the Gulf of California. Many Yaquis were driven
north by the war and some crossed the Arizona border to work in
Tucson`s
citrus
groves. After receiving payment, the Yaquis would spend their money
on weapons and ammunition and then return to Mexico to continue
fighting. The fact that Yaquis were buying arms in Arizona and
smuggling them across the border became so well known that the
military governor of Sonora - General Plutarco Elias Calles,
informally requested help from the United States government in
dealing with the problem. Furthermore, Arizona ranchers began
reporting in larger numbers their encounters with armed Yaquis on
their ranch land or the finding of butchered livestock on the range.
Since there was no United States Border Patrol
at the time,
the task of protecting the border was that of the army, which
operated out of Fort Huachuca.
The
Nogales, Arizona sub-district commander, Colonel
J.C.
Friers, 35th Infantry, responded to the reports by issuing orders to
increase patrolling in the area. American forces in the area included
the 35th Infantry Regiment, stationed at Camp Stephen D. Little in
Nogales, and the 10th Cavalry (colored), the famed Buffalo
Soldiers, who were spread out to protect the various towns near the
international border. A squadron size force from the 10th Cavalry was
encamped about a half mile from the 35th Infantry at Nogales and a
second squadron split up to occupy Lochiel and Campini. Smaller posts
were also established at Arivaca
and
Oro Blanco and finally a troop of about thirty men maintained a camp
at Atascosa Canyon, a "strategic
natural crossing"
within Bear Valley
On
January 8, a local cattleman and owner of the Ruby Mercantile, Philip
C. Clarke, rode into camp and told Captain Ryder that his neighbor
found the body of a cow in the mountains to the north and that pieces
of its hide had been removed for making sandals.
Capt.
Ryder sent 1st. Lt. William Scott and First
Sgt. Samuel H. Alexander with their men
to watch the trails, and about midday the following day, Scott
signaled that the Yaqui were in sight and on the move. Troopers rode
out to the location, dismounted, and advanced in a skirmish line
through a draw but didn’t see the Indians. Heading back to the
horses using a different route, Ryder stumbled upon a cache of
discarded packs. The Yaqui were in the immediate vicinity and knew
they were being pursued. The U.S. troops continued up the canyon
until suddenly the Yaquis fired on them!
My
scenario
I
decided to field 2 groups of Yaqui, one with pack animals carrying
the arms and ammunition and the other a covering party. The US
Cavalry get 3 patrols – 2 on foot and the last mounted.
The
Yaqui start at the end of the arroyo (roughly in the center of the
table) which was about 2ft from the southern edge of the table (I
played on a small table roughly 4 x 4ft) and must get the weapons off
the table moving at 3” per turn.
The
cavalry commander positioned on top of a colina (hill) overlooking
the river crossing directs his patrols towards the fugitives, I
randomised the arrival directions of the three US patrols using the
D8 system I used in my earlier games; at which point the game is on.
Yaqui
Mules
train – 5 Yaqui plus mules
Cover
party – 10 Yaqui (rifle armed)
US
Cavalry
Elements
of “E” Troop 10th Cavalry (colored) under the command of Captain
Frederick H.L. "Blondy" Ryder
1st
foot patrol – 1st Lieutenant William Scott & 9 troopers
2nd
foot patrol – First Sgt. Samuel H. Alexander & 9 troopers
Mounted
patrol – 5 mounted troopers commanded by a corporal
My
table
Because
this is a very simple set-up I actually played two games.
Game
1
Rolling
for the US entry points got: 2, 4 & 7, so the US patrols appeared
all around the Yaqui route of march.
The
mounted patrol coming from the north east
Lieutenant
Scott`s foot
patrol coming from the south east
And
Sgt. Alexander`s foot patrol from the west
The
first two turns saw the Yaqui moving towards the river crossing and
Mexico whilst the cavalry converged on them from all sides.
Turn
3 saw the first shots fired (no hits)
Turn
4 Sgt. Alexander deployed his squad to move in parallel with the
Yaqui in an attempt to outflank and envelope them.
Lt. Scott`s men
advanced from the east and the mounted squad was coming in from the
north east. There is lots of random firing, but no hits were scored.
Turn
5 The Yaqui have now split into two groups the mule train and the
covering party. The covering
indians spread out and engage the cavalry.
Sgt.
Alexander`s men continue their outflanking
move; Lt. Scott`s men advance straight at the enemy as do the mounted
unit. In the exchange of fire, two Yaqui and two troopers are hit
(one from each foot patrol) and the mounted squad decides to dismount
and advance on foot.
The
ex-mounted squad
Lt.
Scott`s men moving to the attack
Turn
6 The Yaqui continue to engage, moving from cover to cover as they
move down the arroyo, the first mule has reached the river. Sgt.
Alexander`s men now have flanking positions on the Yaqui covering
group; Lt. Scott`s men are playing hunt the indian among the rocks
and scrub; the ex-mounted squad moves forward on foot. In the
exchange of fire, the Yaqui lose another two braves without scoring
any hits themselves!
Sgt.
Alexander`s men on the high ground
Lt.
Scott`s men among the rocks
Turn
7 Only one mules remains on the northern, US side of the river. The
Yaqui covering party is in trouble being fired on from east and west
with the ex-mounted squad also closing from the north. In this turns
exchange two more braves fall (including the chief!), the Yaqui do
hit another of Lt. Scott`s patrol.
Turn
8 the last mule escapes into Mexico, the cavalry close on the
remaining Yaqui and they fail their morale check and surrender!
I
declare the result a draw, obviously the casualties were far higher
than the historic incident, but we must assume hits were not always
fatal and unlike Hollywood, a flesh wound can still take a person out
of the fight.
Game
2
I
re-set the Yaqui as before and rolled for US entry, this time we get
7, 6 and 3 – so Sgt. Alexander`s men once again come in from the
west, but the mounted squad are entering from the north west and Lt.
Scott`s men coming in directly from the east.
Again
turns 1 & 2 sees the Yaqui moving down the arroyo whilst the
cavalry close in.
Turn
3 the first long range shots, the Yaqui this time draw first blood
and one of Alexander`s men is hit!
Turn
4 the Yaqui continue to move down the arroyo towards the border and
safety, the cavalry move closer, more shots are exchanged, another of
Alexander`s men is hit, but two Yaqui also go down!
Turn
5 Lt. Scott`s men are now in the fight too, they lose a man but take
two Yaqui. Alexander`s patrol loses another man in exchange for
another Yaqui. The mounted squad bursts out of the arroyo into the
Yaqui rear.
Turn
6 the first mule reaches the river. The Yaqui covering group are
totally overwhelmed by the cavalry with both foot patrols and the
mounted squad charging through them! Another of Alexander`s men is
hit, but the Yaqui lose 5 men, some to close range pistol fire others
to horsemen riding past.
Turn
7 the remaining Yaqui break and run, the mounted squad gallops on
towards the mules.
Turn
8 the mounted squad falls upon the pack mule train, those Yaqui left
north of the river flee abandoning the last mules.
A
complete victory for the 10th Cavalry, though as with the
first game a bit more bloody than history.
Obviously
I`ve run these games solo, but I
think it would work well
with 2 players using
blinds and maybe also
with an umpire running
the Yaqui again using
blinds.
Historic AAR
A
10th Cavalry historian, Col. Harold B. Wharfield, interviewed
fighters from both sides of the fight and wrote the following: The
fighting developed into an old kind of Indian engagement with both
sides using all the natural cover of boulders and brush to full
advantage. The Yaquis kept falling back, dodging from boulder to
boulder and firing rapidly. They offered only a fleeting target,
seemingly just a disappearing shadow. The officer saw one of them
running for another cover, then stumble and thereby expose himself. A
corporal alongside of the captain had a good chance for an open shot.
At the report of the Springfield, a flash of fire enveloped the
Indian’s body for an instant, but he kept on to the rock.”
The
troopers finally overtook a group of ten, who were covering for the
escape of the rest of the band into Mexico, and took them captive.
Ryder later wrote of the engagement that it “was a courageous stand
by a brave group of Indians; and the Cavalrymen treated them with the
respect due to fighting men. Especially astonishing was the discovery
that one of the Yaquis was an eleven-year old boy. The youngster had
fought bravely alongside his elders, firing a rifle that was almost
as long as he was tall.”
Period photo of 10th Cavalry troopers at their camp near Bear Valley
One
of the prisoners, the chief of the group, had been grievously
wounded. “This was the man who had been hit by my corporal’s
shot,” Ryder wrote. “He was wearing two belts of ammunition
around his waist and more over each shoulder. The bullet had hit one
of the cartridges in his belt, causing it to be exploded, making the
flash of fire I saw. Then the bullet entered one side and came out
the other, laying his stomach open.”
The
Cavalry troopers recovered
rifles, a mix of 30-30 Winchester carbines and German made Mausers,
a lot of ammunition, plus powder and lead, and bullet molds.
The
wounded man died the next day and the remaining nine prisoners were
later sent to Tucson for trial in federal court. Charged with
"wrongfully, unlawfully, and feloniously exporting to Mexico
certain arms and ammunition, to wit: 300 rifle cartridges and about 9
rifles without first procuring an export license issued by the War
Trade Board of the United States".
The
Yaquis pleaded guilty and claimed they had not realised soldiers were
US cavalry and thought they had been attacked by Mexican troops! They
claimed that, they would not have fired upon the Americans if they
had realised their mistake as they had no hostility to the US Army or
US citizens. The prisoners were sentenced by judge William Henry
Sawtelle to a mere thirty days in jail, excluding the boy whose
charges were dismissed. Colonel Wharfield wrote that "the
sentence was preferable to the Yaquis who otherwise would be deported
to Mexico and face possible execution as rebels.